Beth Israel Congregation Newsletter
May/June 2006
Iyar/Sivan/Tammuz 5766
Medical Ethics
Conference
May Services at Minnie
Brown
Treasurer's Request
Kitchen Clean Out
Crew
News from the Hebrew
School
Presidents Message
Dump and Run
Mah Jongg
Midcoast Hunger
Prevention
Synagogue Choir
Tedford Shelter
Mid-Coast
Collaborative
Art Spiegelman at Bowdoin
Hillel
Shalom in the Home
A Cantor's Tale
Donations
NOTE: It is our policy that no personal
telephone numbers, email addresses or mailing
addresses be contained in the web version of our
newsletter. If you need to get in touch with one of
our members please email us at
info1@bethisrael-maine.org.
Medical Ethics Conference
The Medical Ethics Conference that was held on
March 26 at the Minnie Brown Center was very well
attended. Each speaker was well prepared and they
each presented their views in a forthright manner.
Also, the breakfast was a big hit. Here are two
notes that summarize the experience.
by Irwin Brodsky MD, MPH
I would like to thank all of the members of
our distinguished panel this morning for a job
well done in generating discussion and expanding
knowledge. Thank you to the Beth Israel Chai
Committee and Board of Directors for your help
with the publicity and logistics. I look forward
to feedback from many quarters to see if it is a
venture we would like to undertake again and to
see how we can improve it.
My bias is that, in a multicultural society
dominated by non-Jewish influence, it is
difficult for many of us to remember what we
offer ourselves, our families, and our
communities by our uniquely Jewish thought
processes and heritage. I hope that more and more
Maine Jews will join together in their community
Synagogues and elsewhere to help each other
remember
by Richard Gelwick, Th.D. Professor
Emeritus
University of New England, Medical
Humanities
Ethics Adjunct Professor, Bangor Theological
Seminary
I want to thank you and all those who helped
to present the conference last Sunday. It was an
outstanding conference in many ways. First, the
panel was well qualified both in medicine and in
ethics from both a Jewish and current
understanding of medical ethics. Second, the use
of cases for discussion worked excellently. I had
never thought before about how naturally Torah
study would work with case study in medical
ethics. Second, the congregation itself was also
very welcoming and insightful.
I was the founding president for 6 years of
the Maine Bioethics Network that lasted from 1992
to 2002 before it collapsed from insufficient
funding. We had conferences several times a year
including at Bates, Maine Medical Center, and
Eastern Maine Medical Center often with
nationally prominent leaders. Your conference
showed again how helpful it is for both lay and
professional persons to meet to discuss these
issues.
May Services at Minnie Brown
by Marilyn Weinberg
Because of the construction at the synagogue,
Friday night services for the month of May will be
held at the Minnie Brown Center. Services will
begin at 7:00 as usual (except for the Tot Shabbat
at 6:30). We hope to be back in the synagogue by
early June, If there are any changes we will send
out an e-mail to let you know. If you are not
already on our e-mail list, please get in touch
with Marilyn Weinberg to make sure you are
added.
Treasurer's Request
by Rea Turet
Beth Israel Congregation's fiscal year ends on
June 30. We would appreciate it if you would
complete payment for your membership dues and
Hebrew School tuition for the 2005-06 year. We
understand that not everybody can pay the full
amount, yet we all need to contribute as best we
can.
Membership dues and Hebrew School tuition should
cover our annual expenses. Yet this year we have
had to take money out of our endowment funds to
meet operating costs. Although fundraising has
helped, we still have a shortfall.
Any payment you make to fulfill your dues and
tuition makes a difference.
Kitchen Clean Out Crew
by Marilyn Weinberg
We had a wonderful crew of volunteers arrive at
the synagogue on a Sunday morning to clear out the
downstairs in preparation for the new construction.
The Boyd family came out in force and moved an
amazing amount of material to the Minnie Brown
Center. Our three stalwart Hyde School students,
Kyle, Mile and Ross, also added their muscle and
enthusiasm to the project. Cleaning out the kitchen
proved to be equally daunting. Thanks to Peggy
Brown, Lynn Frank, Norma Dreyfus, Stanley Lane, Rea
Turet, Barbara Leeman and Fred Weinberg for all
their hard work.
News from the Hebrew School
by Barbara Leeman
By the next bulletin, our school year will have
ended. We have had a busy year. This year was an
opportunity to continue many of the programs that
had success in past, and try out some new things as
well. As we move forward next year, we will again
send out a survey, and take feedback to help our
Hebrew school continue to grow better each and
every year.
Purim Carnival
For all who came to the Megillah reading and
Purim carnival, the spirit and enthusiasm with
which our children joined in, made all the planning
worthwhile. It was a wonderful success. Our biggest
thanks go to Lauri Gallimore, who planned and
organized the carnival, and got many members
involved. Cantor Daniel read the Megillah in both
English and Hebrew, engaged everyone in questions,
and enthusiastically led us in joyful singing. The
kids paraded in costume to the Minnie Brown Center,
where they had games, face painting, crafts,
fortune telling, and refreshments. The kids had
shaloch manot exchanges, while the parents
collected food and other items for those in need.
The Wednesday right before the carnival (March 15),
the kids made their own Hamentashen at Hebrew
school. Everyone enjoyed tasting their efforts. We
thank all involved. It was a wonderful community
effort.
Class Shabbat Services
Our Aleph class led us beautifully in our
Shabbat service on March 17. Those who participated
were Sullivan Boyd, Zelda Clegg, Nicholas Hagler,
Arielle Leeman, Emma Miller, Sadie Pressman, Henry
Raker, and Noa Sreden. Isaac Boll is also an active
member of this class. Our Aleph class teacher is
Tinker Hannaford and Jane Martell is the student
helper in the class. We are very grateful for their
work with this class. As always, we enjoyed a
wonderful Shabbat meal prior to the service, with
zmirot (Shabbat melodies) and all. Mazel Tov to
everyone!
Passover Seder
On April 5, our school began to get into the
Passover mood by having a model Seder. Daniel led
the seder, while the kids participated in leading
different parts. We were able to go through much of
the Hagaddah while having fun in the process.
Special thanks to Deb Hagler and Chris Schoenberg,
who came early to set up the room, flowers and all.
Deb's homemade macaroons finished our meal with
sweetness. A huge thank you to all who helped pull
it all together and brought many Seder items.
Gan Class
Our Gan class (kindergarten) will be leading our
service on May 19. This was originally scheduled
for April 28, so please change your calendars, and
plan to join us. This group includes Tobyn Blatt,
Ethan Boll, Avi Gersh, Rebecca Maniscalco, Abigail
and Zoe Sreden. We look forward to having this
wonderful group lead us.
Special Thanks
Marilyn Weinberg stepped in to cover a class in
time of need. The kids definitely benefited from
her wisdom and enthusiasm. Thank you for being a
great substitute.
Yom Hashoah
On Wednesday, April 26, the grades 3-6 had a
chance to view the movie Paperclips. This very
inspiring movie about a little town in Tennessee,
decided it was time to learn about diversity. The
students of Whitwell Middle school began collecting
paperclips, hoping to collect 6 million
representing each of the Jews killed in the
holocaust. They ultimately collected well over 20
million, and learned about the Holocaust in a very
unique way, from survivors, German citizens and
others who became interested in their project. This
video was a great way for our students to see how
other students their age honored the lives of those
lost in the Holocaust, and how even today, we can
still make a difference.
School Pictures
School pictures were taken on April 5. Copies
will be sent to each family through email when they
are available.
Israeli Dancing
In honor of Yom Ha'Azmaut (Israel Independence
Day) we are going to have an educational Israeli
dancing session on May 3. Lisa Tessler gave the
kids a great introduction to many different dance
steps last year, and she will be enhancing on those
while introducing more this year. This is a
favorite event (not to be missed) amongst our
kids.
Lag B'Omer
We will celebrate Lag B'Omer on May 17, by
having our outdoor games and ice cream party
following Hebrew school, on the Patten Free library
lawn across the street. Feel free to bring a picnic
dinner and relax with us. Festivities begin at 6pm,
following Hebrew school, and last for no more than
one hour.
Vav Class Graduation
We have a number of students who have been with
us at our Hebrew school many years. Our students
will be graduating, and moving onto private study,
where they will prepare for their Bar/Bat Mitzvah.
Our graduating class will lead services on June 2
(originally on the calendar as June 9, but moved),
as we celebrate Shavuot, the anniversary of the
giving of the Torah on Mount Sinai. This special
Bikkurim service will include the Reading of the
Book of Ruth and will be led by the following
students: Ethan Blatt, Hannah and Sam Leeman,
Rebecca Lewis, Nina Maris, Sarah Neuren, and Rachel
Schoenberg. It should be a wonderful service for
all involved and all others who come.
Tzedakah
The kids have been donating all year, and during
the month of May, they will vote on the recipients
of their Tzedakah dollars. Don't forget to bring in
your ideas.
Parent Committee Meeting
Our next and last parent committee meeting is on
May 3. Feel free to come and join the planning for
next year.
Presidents Message
by Marilyn Weinberg
So what are you doing on June 4? Hopefully you
will be joining us at the Beth Israel Congregation
Annual Meeting. We have had a full year. Our Hebrew
school is thriving and we have an upcoming summer
filled with services and Bar/Bat Mitzvah
celebrations. Services throughout the year have
been interesting and varied. Our Hebrew School
children have led services every month and we have
had interesting and thought provoking presentations
from members and guest speakers.
Yet we are still a small congregation trying to
meet the needs of many people with different views
of what it means to be Jewish and how a synagogue
should function. How do we proceed? What should our
priorities be? How do we raise the money to support
all of our programs? Our dues still do not meet our
operating expenses. The Annual Meeting is your
opportunity to share your views and help shape our
future direction. If you know of something you
would like to change, be part of the solution.
Come!
The Annual Meeting will be held on Sunday, June
4 at the Minnie Brown Center. Bagels, juice and
coffee will be served at 9:30 am. The meeting will
begin at 10:00 am.
Dump and Run
by Barbara Leeman
Bowdoin's Dump and Run 2006 - the big end of the
year student move-out program, is soon approaching.
As students are clearing out their dorm rooms, and
returning home for the summer, they find there are
many items they don't need or want. These items get
donated by the students, and then collected, sorted
and sold by volunteers (us). Depending on how many
volunteer hours we are able to provide, will
determine how big a percentage of the profits come
back to Beth Israel. The whole community benefits.
For those of you who have participated before, you
know it is a lot of work, but a great way to raise
money for our congregation while also keeping a lot
of usable goods out of the Brunswick landfill. It
also provides great deals for people in the
community.
Many non-profits have heard about this
fundraiser, and there is considerable competition
to get shifts. There were some shifts that we asked
for, that we got, and other shifts that were given
to Beth Israel, that we did not actually sign up
for. We have open spots that we need to fill for
Memorial Day weekend (1:30-5:00 pm shifts), or
Thursday, June 8th (1:30-5:00 pm). If you find you
are available, and want to do a mitzvah, please
email or call.
Many people were able to give of their time
generously last year. We earned over $1000 for Beth
Israel. This was really wonderful, since everyone
put in only a few hours each. Some had so much fun,
they took more than one shift. I hope many will
consider helping this year.
Please contact me as soon as you know that you
can make a commitment to help.
Bam, Crack, Mah Jongg's Back!
by Emily Sandberg
The JCA is offering a new series of Mah Jongg
lessons. This will be a three-week refresher
course, although beginners are also welcome.
Mah Jongg is an incredibly popular social game
that spans many generations.
Please join us for three consecutive Wednesday
evenings or Monday afternoons and be taught by our
wonderful volunteer instructors. Light refreshments
will be served.
WHEN & WHERE:
Wednesdays, May 3 and 10 from 7:00-9:00 pm at the
Jewish Community Alliance
OR
Mondays, May 1, 8, and 15 from 1:00-3:00 pm at The
Atrium at The Cedars
COST:
$15 for three-week session. Fee includes required
card that you will receive the first lesson.
REGISTRATION:
Please call Leslie Cyr at the JCA at 772-1959
Call soon! There is limited space for this
program and it will fill quickly. Call Emily
Sandberg with questions.
Midcoast Hunger Prevention
by Jill Standish
Meals are needed for a member of our community.
Please contact Joanne Rosenthal at home or work if
you are able to help. Thank you.
The Sunday morning food project with the
Midcoast Hunger Prevention Program is underway.
More volunteers are needed for a once a month
commitment. Please contact Jill Standish to learn
more.
Synagogue Choir
by Evelyn Panish and Cantor Daniel Leeman
Do you like to sing? Do you enjoy the songs and
chants that we sing during our Shabbat services?
Evelyn Panish was a member of the choir of her
previous synagogue and would like to see one
launched at Beth Israel. Cantor Dan is willing to
help and work with the group. We just need singers.
You do not need to be able to read Hebrew. If you
would like to be part of this new group, please
contact Evelyn Panish or Cantor Daniel Leeman.
Tedford Shelter
by Ed & Ruth Benedikt
The Tedford Shelter "Homelessness to Hope"
initiative represents a giant step forward from the
traditional shelter programs which provide
temporary lodgings for the homeless. Anyone working
in this field quickly learns that a significant
portion of the homeless population cycles in and
out of such last-hope facilities, as their fragile
grip on housing repeatedly falls before the same
personal problems and inadequacies. This new
project in the Bath-Brunswick area is designed to
combine rooms or apartments with centrally based
counseling and referral services that help address
problems of substance abuse, mental illness, lack
of job skills and behaviors, illiteracy, etc.
It is a basic tenet of tzedakah that the highest
and noblest form of charity is to enable people to
be self-sufficient. For that reason, although many
members of Congregation Beth Israel have already
been involved in the Tedford Shelter's ambitious
project to combat homelessness, we think it would
be helpful and appropriate for the Beth Israel
Congregation to give a warm endorsement of this
project.
Since many of our members live in the
communities in which these new units will be built,
this could be, in part, a gesture of welcome. Every
one of us must make our own choices on the amount
and the recipients of our personal charitable
contributions, but we can all be a part of
endorsing this remarkable project and of expressing
our organizational approval and support.
Let's get involved. Contact Ed or Ruth to find
out how.
Mid-Coast Collaborative
by Ed & Ruth Benedikt
For the last eighteen months, the Mid-Coast
Collaborative for Access to Transportation (A
Brunswick-Topsham Community Action Group) has been
looking at the issues related to transportation in
the Brunswick and Topsham area. Particularly we
have been focusing on the needs of individuals who
have difficulty or inability to drive themselves,
for whatever reason. We are now in a position where
we know much more than we did at the outset about
the issues and have proposed some possible
solutions that includes partnerships with
non-profit and religious groups.
There is a widespread acknowledgement that the
lack of public transportation has effects that are
deeply felt throughout our communities. We heard
from people who felt isolated and unable to
participate in the activities that make for a
meaningful life because they could not afford a
ride.
One solution that has been suggested would
address the off hour, weekend and more spontaneous
needs that have been repeatedly raised by many
residents. This solution could take a number of
forms, but it would develop a volunteer network,
and the capacity to link people needing rides with
those providing them. The Town of Brunswick, the
Maine DOT, Coastal Transport , many community
groups and the Brunswick Area Interfaith Council (
on which I represent Beth Israel) has been
wonderfully supportive throughout, and we believe a
successful partnership using volunteers can happen
here.
Are any members of our congregation from
Brunswick or Topsham willing to provide rides to
those less fortunate?
Art Spiegelman at Bowdoin Hillel
by Cantor Daniel Leeman
As one of Hillel's advisors at the Bowdoin
College Campus, it is a pleasure each year to
attend a dinner reception and special Spindell
lecture. The lecture is sponsored by the Bernstein
family of Portland in memory of Harry Spindell, Roz
Bernstein's father. Roz was also married to the
late Sumner Bernstein, whom I had the pleasure of
knowing as an acquaintance and respected attorney
and Jewish community leader in Portland back in the
late 1980's.
This year's choice was an outstanding figure,
Art Spiegelman, the Pulitzer prize winning author.
He is best known for his graphic novel series
"Maus, a survivor's tale." This was an easy read.
It leapt off the page for the child in all of us,
who likes to look at pictures while reading.
Because he was coming to campus, it was required
reading as part of First- Year student orientation
this fall.
It's a work that depicts Jews as mice and Nazis
as cats. In his presentation on the podium at a
packed auditorium of some 300 souls, Mr. Spiegelman
combined the humility of a solid, down to earth
neighborly type, with the artistry of someone who
feels so deeply that it hurts to witness some of
his work. He has the gift of being able to quietly
display the profound depth of his emotions in the
symbols and pithy writing of his craft. He was able
to convey his images, both literally and
figuratively. He shared his life experience,
although harsh, for all to see, as he clicked
through his slide presentations.
For those who don't know his work, he described
a desire to create a "comic book that required a
bookmark." Back in the seventies, the graphic novel
was a new art form. As the child of Holocaust
survivors, growing up in Washington Heights, in
northern Manhattan among many other children of
survivors, he witnessed the difficult and sometimes
broken world of survivor families. He found refuge
in the heroes of the comic books. The book series,
"Maus," is mostly about the troubled relationship
he had with his father. His father was depicted as
a difficult, nervous man, who could be overbearing
and annoying. One poignant aspect of the book was
how his father hoarded food. He used to return
unused portions of open packages of food to the
supermarket.
When I met and asked Mr. Spiegelman about it, he
explained that some survivors were profligate, and
couldn't hold on to a penny. They felt they needed
to live for today, and not worry about tomorrow.
Others couldn't waste anything, always hoarding,
saving, almost miserly in behavior. He implied that
his father, alas, fit into this latter
category.
One of the most powerful images he shared with
the group was entitled "Future." It was a drawing
of himself as a mouse and his father, sitting on
the floor in front of a couch in his own living
room, beside his young four-year-old daughter. They
were reading together in a lovely scene. Yet,
looming in the background as if as a mural on the
wall behind them out of their sight, but
over-arching in ours, was the shadow of hanging
mice. It was a veiled depiction of Jewish bodies
left hanging for days at the gallows by the Nazis.
The title "Future" gave me shivers as his beautiful
young mouse-like daughter was enjoying her father's
love and attention. The tender love of a father was
clear, yet the darkness of the Holocaust seemed to
over-shadow all there was in their young lives and
in their relationship. (I found this image of the
"future" both profoundly sad and beautifully
hopeful at the same time.) This is what makes the
man, Spiegelman, and his story, Maus, so
compelling. Because he and his work combine the
two, both pain and hope.
Another painful personal element to Spiegelman's
life, was that his Mom committed suicide. He
explained that after surviving the Nazi's she
didn't want to go on. She married Vladek, Art's
father, and gave birth to Art because of Vladek's
pleading. Vladek wanted her to go on with life and
overcome their harsh experience. She tried but
eventually couldn't any longer. Our guest lecturer
showed slides of his renderings of his mother's
funeral. It was gut-wrenching and powerful. One of
the slides was black, with giant tears.
Spiegelman tried to be clear that he wasn't
trying to make any statements about the Jewish
experience. He wasn't trying to point to the future
or explain the past. He explained that back, when
he was embarking on the writing of Maus, he
consulted his wife about his plan. She advised him
not to worry about the implications of his work.
She said "Just keep it real." So this is what
Spiegelman set as his goal, and he succeeded.
Through his work he shares the pain and hope of the
Jewish experience. We're grateful that he came to
visit our Jewish community.
Shalom in the Home
by Cantor Daniel Leeman
Rabbi Shmuel Boteach is a remarkable figure. His
training is as a Lubavitch Rabbi. He worked in
England at Oxford University where he created a
vibrant Jewish community called the L'Chayim Club
(to life club) that has spread its Jewish message
to Cambridge and to London. He began working on
television and radio with the BBC and now has
launched a fascinating series on The Learning
Channel in the US.
He is best known for his sensationalist book
entitled "Kosher Sex." The book grew out of his
experience counseling college and university
students on the do's and don'ts of sexual
experimentation. He's a traditional, and
knowledgeable Rabbi, while being a sensitive and
insightful observer of personal and intimate
relationships.
The new US television series on TLC is entitled
Shalom in the Home. I've seen a couple of episodes
and they are terrific. I'll describe one episode
about a family in crisis. The parents divorced two
years prior because of the father's infidelity, and
have been in fight mode ever since.
The rabbi arrives as a larger than life presence
and lives in his "Airstream" camper van for a week.
He parks beside the troubled family home and places
cameras inside and communicates with the family via
invisible ear pieces. He forces wrong doers to
confess, and gives practical, reasonable,
insightful advice on the best ways to proceed to
keep peace at home.
He is vigorous at encouraging parent's to exert
their authority, and take charge on issues of loud
unruly behavior and teen sex. He encourages
families to play together and thereby create great
memories of loving times and experiences. He
demands hard work and respect from everyone. It is
a beautiful and much needed series. I only hope he
can continue his positive influence and maintain
his imaginative and creative approaches to solving
family problems.
Rabbi Boteach himself was born to parents who
divorced when he was a child. The most beautiful
element to this show is that the pain and
loneliness he experienced as a child, that has
stayed with him, inspired him to dedicate his work
to help families in distress. He helps to create a
peaceful, happy home in which children can be
raised. There's a type of perfection to this
approach to life that I believe really has a
sanctity that shines.
A Cantor's Tale
by Cantor Daniel Leeman
I was invited by board members of the Maine
Jewish Film Festival to help moderate a discussion
after the screening of A Cantor's Tale, one of the
films shown at the festival last month. There were
about 150 people in attendance and I shared the
delightful task of leading the discussion with
Cantor Ruth Ross of Temple Beth El in Portland,
Maine.
The subject of the biographical documentary
film, and star of the film, was Jacob "Jack"
Mendelson, a Cantorial colleague and acquaintance
of mine of some 20 years. Although I've met and
chatted cordially with Jack on numerous occasions
at annual Cantors Assembly Conventions, this film
was an extraordinary insight I'd never seen into
his character and career.
The film-maker, Eric Greenberg Anjou, did a
masterful job weaving together the various venues
and practices in the life of the community Cantor.
We saw Jack in concert, we saw him teaching at the
Cantorial School of Hebrew Union College in NYC, we
saw him singing with and teaching the kindergarten
class at the Conservative Synagogue in which he
serves in White Plains, NY. We also saw him in his
element, the old village of Boro Park, in Brooklyn
recounting his remembrances of his childhood in
Brooklyn in the late 1940's.
The film gives the viewer a rare glimpse of a
world imported from the shtetyl of Europe, where
the Cantor was one of the town's great musical
personalities. The film described and demonstrated
the great genius and vocal mastery of such cantors
as Hirshman, Rosenblatt, Kwartin, and Kousevitsky.
During interviews with Mendelson and others, we
listened in the background, often swelling to the
surface, to their golden voices together with their
select male choirs. There were interviews with
Jack's friends, who are arguably some of today's
great cantors, Malovany of the Fifth Avenue
Synagogue in NYC, Ben-Tzion Miller, of Brooklyn,
Abe Mizrahi of Chicago. Also interviewed were some
of the great proponents of Jewish Musical
composition and choral music, like Mati Lazar, the
founder of the "Zamire Chorale," and its newest
offshoot, "Hazamir," the international teen Jewish
choral movement.
There were also simple exchanges with his
buddies, lovers and collectors of Jewish music
recordings, who know the great cantorial masters as
icons and community heroes. One exchange that has
stuck firmly in my memory was when Jack described
the capes, the swagger, the shiny shoes and cane of
the master cantor, who always traveled with a
retinue of followers. These followers consisted of
choristers and literally Ôgroupies' of that
generation. He explained how cantorial music was in
the air, on the street, on the radio. The average
Jewish person knew the music as we today know pop
stars' music. Concerts of Jewish music were sold
out, packed, bursting with excitement and
energy.
It is rumored that the film would never have
come to be, had not this young film-maker had a
mid-life crisis of sorts. Apparently, he mistakenly
considered that his choice to become a film-maker,
and his developed accomplishments and expertise
were not as important as a career which he may have
preferred, as a Cantor. So Anjou apparently left
his illustrious life as a film-maker temporarily,
to find a mentor and to learn to become a Cantor.
He found and befriended Jack Mendelson and became a
regular of his cantorial classes, his synagogue,
and even was a house-guest, enjoying Sabbath and
Holiday meals at the family's home in White Plains.
One could conclude that from Anjou's personal
crisis and career change exploration, came this gem
of a film.
One fascinating aspect of the film was the way
Jack described his relationship to his family,
especially his mother. His parents ran a Kosher
Deli and left him at home alone a lot as a child.
He spent his time listening to Cantorial recordings
over and over. He describes his mother as one of
those fanatic lovers of every aspect of the
cantorial world (a groupie) and that she had
decided FOR her two boys that they both would
become professional Cantors. At the time, a woman
hadn't the option to become a community Cantor, so
perhaps teaching one's sons to become Cantors was
the next best thing for her.
Jack explains that he was not much of a student
at the Yeshiva and was expelled. He went to the
local public high school and also failed. He never
graduated high school. After a very brief stint as
a professional gambler, he took refuge at his
brother's home in Long Beach, New York for the
summer (his brother Sol was also a Cantor and later
became president of the Cantors Assembly). In the
fall he became a student at the Hebrew Union
College's Cantorial School, a branch of the Reform
Movement. Coming from an orthodox home and the
Yeshiva world, this choice was a shock to his
family and community. But the Cantorial world is
what he knew and loved. He paid some of his tuition
by working as a waiter at the famous Kosher
Restaurant, Ratner's, in Brooklyn.
What 'spiced-up' the whole film were interview
accounts from some of Mendelson's famous friends.
These included Alan Dershowitz, and Jackie Mason.
They hilariously described their experience as
children in the Cantorial choirs in Brooklyn and
what it was like in the neighborhood. At one point
Mendelson pointed across the street and said "That
was Sandy Koufax's house. His father was the local
dentist." He pointed to another small store with a
counter soda fountain and said "David Geffen used
to drink egg creams (a type of milk shake) at that
dime store." He went on to say "Steven Spielberg's
uncle used to deliver hot-dogs right here, to my
parent's deli." He shared all these memories with
warmth, charm, and charisma.
All together, the film was bittersweet for me. I
felt Jack has tried his whole life to preserve an
art form that is rapidly fading. He gave us a taste
of a Jewish world pulsing from the horror of WWII
and the miraculous hopefulness embodied in the new
State of Israel. Yes, Jewish music of all kinds is
burgeoning beautifully today and being recorded for
all of us to enjoy. But it is mostly new
compositions, or modern music with Jewish themes.
One may describe the change as the plaintiff cry of
the shtetyl Cantor being transformed into the
joyous celebration of Jewish life in America and
Israel. Yet, one could also view the golden age of
the Cantorial Master as a world going by. The
Nusach (Jewish musical mode) of the synagogue has
been partially preserved, but these model chants
seem to be giving way to a new sound. The film
depicts a man's life and love of a musical genre
that has changed so dramatically and really no
longer exists as he knew it. Mendelson seems to
cling to the cantor's music as hopefully as the
Haredim (Ultra Orthodox) cling to the Western wall.
As the prophet Ezekiel wrote in this week's Shabbos
and Pesach Haftorah : Hatichyena Ha'atzamot
Ha'ayleh? Will these bones yet live?
Donations
The following members have made donations to
Beth Israel Congregation. We thank them for their
generosity:
- Sharon Drake, in memory of her father, Edward
Kravitz
- Andrew Schoenberg, in memory of his mother,
Elayne Schoenberg
- Rea Turet and Sandy Polster in memory of her
father, Maurice Turet
- Daniel and Barbara Leeman
- Ann Marks in honor of Lori and Irwin
Brodsky's Twentieth Anniversary
-
In memory of Frances Weinberg, Fred Weinberg's
mother
- Marilyn and Fred Weinberg
- Richard and Judy Gelles
- Ann Isacoff
- Lenore and Jay Friedland
- Dan and Susan Levey
We thank the following friends of Beth Israel
Congregation for their generosity:
- Thomas Stetson
- Ruth Belchez and Peter Dessereau
|